1
18
Lime Pawpaw
Towns Folk
For me, Resident Evil: The Mercenaries 3D. I got it for $12, which is about right (subsequent sales in 2015 have made it go down to $8, but still) and best of all, the guy who had the game before me hadn't even played it; the game's undeletable save file which it was criticized a lot for didn't affect me at all and I got it cheap and relatively early