Dis was well, said and on point. Good job.
I my self doesn't like horror genre all that much (especially the jupmscares one) not because I hate it, it's just that I deal badly with these type of game, however, if I ever play a story oriented games I will try to get every bits of the story out of it (considering that I doesn't own my own PCs this chance is pretty rare indeed.) for example, if I ever play outlast or something more story heavy like corpse party, I would rather wonder around before proceeding on the main story.
With all that said, it's just my opinion. One thing for sure is that not many people like to read everything like me. And I think I can deal with psychological horror pretty well because I tend to look at the game features as a part of the story, in example tell tale's walking dead. If a choices appeared I only look at it as a choice you have to make to progress the story, no matter who died by said choice is not relevant to me. I also have a low tendency to grown attached to a character.