(and screw it, because I'm nice)
Monokuma went over to Cal's cottage. He found him sleeping after his eye sugary, wearing an eye patch.
Monokuma: WAKE UP YOU MORON, BODIES ARE BEING DISCOVERED!!!
Cal woke up, looking sleepy, muttering something about some weird dream he had about losing his other eye. He felt his working eye, and to his relief, found it was still intact and hadnt been stabbed with a knife. "Must have been a dream" Cal said to himself. Monokuma gave him a weird look and walked away.
Before he left, he handed Cal a gouged out eye
Monokuma: Try NOT to lose it this time.
He left a very confused Cal to investigate