I would politely tell you to annoy someone else if you tried that on me.
I really can't stand pick-up lines. If you want to start something with a girl, just say "Hey", start a conversation and see where it goes. Pick-up lines about eyes are still classier than some other things I've heard but you'd be better of just acting like a normal person.
Now, for REALLY terrible pick-up lines:
"Hey gurl, I see you fell from the ugly tree and hit every branch."
"Did you fall from heaven? 'Cause your face looks smashed in."
Or a classic: "Hey gurl, do you believe in love at first sight or should I walk by again?"
The direct approach: "Nice shoes"
One not so terrible (but still worse than none at all):
"You're so beautiful you made me forget my pick up line"